Scott Trigg Brown-Bag Talk (HPS/History): Reading the Cosmos: Commentaries and the Education of an Islamic Astronomer


Location: 118 O'Shaughnessy Hall (View on map )

The History and Philosophy of Science Graduate Program presents a brown-bag talk by Scott Trigg, HPS Postdoctoral Fellow. Late medieval Islamic commentaries are a potentially rich but little-used source for historians to explore how ideas about science and religion were transmitted, criticized, and revised both in and outside of formal educational institutions. In this paper, Trigg discusses examples taken from the previously unstudied commentaries of Fatḥallāh al-Shirwānī, a 15th c. astronomer and theologian who trained at the famous Samarqand observatory and was associated with the Ottoman sultan Mehmed II in Istanbul. In particular, Shirwānī’s commentary on Naṣīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī’s al-Tadhkira fī ʿilm al-hayʾa provides a glimpse inside a medieval classroom, introducing the reader to the theory and practice of astronomy while relating anecdotes from Shirwānī’s student days in Samarqand. Thus, the commentary provides an important case study of scientific education in Islamic society during a formative period in the creation of the modern world.

Originally published at